Notes to the group financial statements l Note 5.2

5.2 Intangible assets and goodwill
 

Goodwill

Goodwill is measured at cost less accumulated impairment losses and is not amortised but tested for impairment annually.

As the functional currencies of MTN South Sudan Company Limited and MTN Syria (JSC) are currencies of hyperinflationary economies, goodwill relating to these subsidiaries is restated by applying the change in the general price indices from the date of acquisition to the current reporting date.

Goodwill arising on the acquisition of subsidiaries is included in intangible assets. Goodwill arising on the acquisition of an associate or joint venture is included in ‘Investment in associates and joint ventures’, and is tested for impairment as part of the overall balance.

Gains or losses on the disposal of an entity include the carrying amount of goodwill allocated to the entity sold.

The group annually reviews the carrying amounts of intangible assets with indefinite useful lives for impairments. The recoverable amounts of the assets are estimated in order to determine the extent, if any, of the impairment loss.

Intangible assets with finite useful lives

The group’s intangible assets with finite useful lives are as follows:

  • Licences;
  • Customer relationships;
  • Computer software; and
  • Other intangible assets.

Intangible assets with finite useful lives are measured at historical cost less accumulated amortisation and impairment losses. Intangible assets acquired through business combinations are initially shown at fair value and are subsequently carried at the initially determined fair value less accumulated amortisation and impairment losses. The initial cost incurred in respect of licences is capitalised. Contingent licence fees are expensed as they are incurred.

As the functional currencies of MTN South Sudan Company Limited and MTN Syria (JSC) are currencies of hyperinflationary economies, intangible assets relating to these subsidiaries are restated by applying the change in the general price indices from the date of acquisition to the current reporting date.

Amortisation is calculated on a straight-line basis to write off the cost of intangible assets over their estimated useful lives. Amortisation relating to MTN South Sudan Company Limited and MTN Syria (JSC) is based on the restated amounts, which have been adjusted for the effects of hyperinflation.

Useful lives are reviewed on an annual basis with the effects of any changes in estimate accounted for on a prospective basis. The residual values of intangible assets are assumed to be zero.

The bases for determining the useful lives for the various categories of intangible assets is as follows:

Licences

The useful lives are determined primarily with reference to the unexpired licence period.

Customer relationships

The useful life principally reflects management’s view of the average economic life of the customer base and is assessed by reference to factors such as customer churn rates. An increase in churn rates may lead to a reduction in the estimated useful life.

Software

The useful life is determined with reference to the licence term of the computer software. For unique software products controlled by the group, the useful life is based on historical experience with similar assets as well as anticipation of future events such as technological changes, which may impact the useful life.

Other intangible assets

Useful lives are based on management’s estimates and take into account historical experience as well as future events which may impact the useful lives. The estimated useful lives of intangible assets with finite useful lives are as follows:

 

   2017 
Years
 
   2016 
Years 
  
Licences  3 – 20     3 – 20    
Customer relationships  5 – 10     5 – 10    
Software  3 – 6     3 – 6    
Other intangible assets  3 – 10     3 – 10    

The gain or loss arising on the disposal or retirement of an intangible asset is included in profit or loss.

Development costs that are directly attributable to the design and testing of identifiable and unique software products controlled by the group are recognised as intangible assets when the following criteria are met:

  • it is technically feasible to complete the software so that it will be available for use;
  • management intends to complete the software and use or sell it;
  • there is an ability to use or sell the software;
  • it can be demonstrated how the software will generate probable future economic benefits;
  • adequate technical, financial and other resources to complete the development and to use or sell the software are available; and
  • the expenditure attributable to the software during its development can be reliably measured.

Directly attributable costs that are capitalised as part of the software include employee costs and an appropriate portion of relevant overheads. Capitalised development costs are recorded as intangible assets and amortised from the point at which the asset is ready for use.

Costs associated with maintaining software programs are recognised as an expense as incurred. Research and development expenditure that does not meet the criteria above is recognised as an expense as incurred. Development costs previously recognised as an expense are not recognised as an asset in a subsequent period.

Expenditure that enhances or extends the performance of intangible assets beyond their original specifications is recognised as a capital improvement and capitalised to the original cost of the assets. Expenditure on research activities is recognised as an expense in the period in which it is incurred.

Determination of fair values

The fair value of customer relationships acquired in a business combination is determined using the multi-period excess earnings method, whereby the subject asset is valued after deducting a fair return on all other assets that are part of creating the related cash flows.

The fair value of patents and trademarks acquired in a business combination is based on the discounted estimated royalty payments that have been avoided as a result of the patent or trademark being owned.

The fair values of all other intangible assets acquired in a business combination applicable to the group are based on the discounted cash flows expected to be derived from the use and eventual sale of the assets.

Impairment

An impairment loss is recognised in profit or loss if the carrying amount of an asset or a CGU exceeds its estimated recoverable amount. For the purpose of impairment testing, assets are grouped together into CGUs. The recoverable amount of an asset or CGU is the higher of its value in use and its fair value less costs of disposal. In assessing value in use, the estimated future cash flows are discounted to their present value using a pre-tax discount rate that reflects current market assessments of the time value of money and the risks specific to the asset.

Impairment losses recognised in respect of CGUs are allocated first to reduce the carrying amount of any goodwill allocated to the units and then to reduce the carrying amounts of the other assets in the unit (group of units) on a pro rata basis.

An impairment loss is subsequently reversed only to the extent that the asset or CGU’s carrying amount does not exceed the carrying amount that would have been determined had no impairment loss been recognised. A reversal of an impairment loss is recognised immediately in profit or loss.

An impairment loss in respect of goodwill is not reversed.

 
   Goodwill 
Rm 
Licences 
Rm 
Customer 
relationships 
Rm 
Software1
Rm 
Other 
intangible 
assets 
Rm 
Capital 
work in 
progress 
Rm 
Total 
Rm 
  
Carrying amount at 1 January 2016  27 231  19 100  664  8 169  484  239  55 887    
Additions2, 5  –  3 298  12  1 867  7  1 305  6 489    
Acquisitions through business combinations  229  –  455  1  –  –  685    
Disposals  (117) (15) –  –  –  –  (132)   
Reallocations4  –  (37) (49) 957  (205) (634) 32    
Amortisation for the year  –  (1 798) (206) (2 733) (11) –  (4 748)   
Impairment loss  (873) –  –  (30) –  –  (903)   
Other movements  49  (169) 9  262  (9) (7) 135    
Effect of movements in exchange rates3  (4 451) (5 564) (2) (892) (16) (47) (10 972)   
Carrying amount at 31 December 2016  22 068  14 815  883  7 601  250  856  46 473    
Comprising:                         
Cost  25 478  23 746  1 341  17 949  5 413  856  74 783    
Accumulated amortisation and impairment losses  (3 410) (8 931) (458) (10 348) (5 163) –  (28 310)   
   22 068  14 815  883  7 601  250  856  46 473    
Carrying amount at 1 January 2017  22 068  14 815  883  7 601  250  856  46 473    
Additions2, 5  –  699  –  2 197  9  1 260  4 165    
Disposals  –  –  –  –  –  –  –    
Reallocations  –  105  –  1 355  –  (1 258) 202    
Amortisation for the year  –  (1 703) (205) (2 579) (3) –  (4 490)   
(Impairment loss)/impairment loss reversal6  (2 631) (533) –  (17) 23  –  (3 158)   
Other movements  –  –  –  –  (25) 1  (24)   
Effect of movements in exchange rates3  (2 799) (1 672) (1) (365) 3  (4) (4 838)   
Carrying amount at 31 December 2017  16 638  11 711  677  8 192  257  855  38 330    
Comprising:                         
Cost  22 679  21 045  1 341  20 074  5 375  855  71 369    
Accumulated amortisation and impairment losses  (6 041) (9 334) (664) (11 882) (5 118) –  (33 039)   
   16 638  11 711  677  8 192  257  855  38 330    
1 Included in software are leased assets with a carrying amount of R690 million (2016: R739 million).
2 Included in additions are capitalised borrowing costs of R11 million (2016: R25 million). The capitalisation rate for the year was 8,6% (2016: 8,6%).
3 Includes the effect of hyperinflation.
4 Included in reallocations is an amount of R254 million relating to intangible assets reallocated to non-current assets held for sale which were disposed of in 2016.
5 Included in additions is internally generated software amounting to R701 million (2016: R1 134 million).
6 The impairment loss in respect of licences included an amount of R172 million and R354 million relating to MTN Sudan and MTN Syria, respectively, for the current financial year.
5.2.1

Goodwill

A summary of the goodwill allocation and related assumptions applied for impairment testing purposes is presented below:

   2017      2016    
   Growth
rate
% 
Discount
rate
% 
Carrying
amount
Rm 
   Growth
rate
% 
Discount
rate
% 
Carrying
amount
Rm 
  
MTN Côte d’Ivoire S.A.  2,0  9,7  2 682     2,0  11,4  2 678    
Scancom Limited (MTN Ghana) 6,0  17,5  4 330     6,0  20,0  5 293    
MTN Sudan Company Limited  14,0  39,0  –     13,7  32,9  1 214    
MTN Yemen  9,0  31,7  1 202     9,0  23,9  2 950    
MTN Afghanistan Limited  6,0  17,6  490     7,0  20,2  1 482    
MTN Uganda Limited  5,0  15,1  551     5,0  17,3  618    
MTN Congo S.A.  2,4  16,0  909     3,6  17,0  891    
MTN Syria (JSC) 15,0  41,9  –     15,0  35,5  –    
MTN Cyprus Limited  2,0  10,1  787     1,9  9,5  759    
Spacetel Benin S.A.  2,0  24,7  1 192     2,3  11,3  1 190    
Areeba Guinea S.A.  7,9  22,0  –     5,0  22,7  –    
Mobile Telephone Networks Proprietary Limited (South Africa) 5,5  12,0  2 583     5,5  13,3  2 583    
Lonestar Communications Corporation LLC (Liberia) 7,1  25,0  312     7,5  23,4  350    
MTN Rwandacell  5,0  15,1  313     5,0  17,3  361    
MTN Nigeria Communications Limited (Visafone) 14,5  25,5  345     9,1  20,6  439    
MTN Zambia  8,0  19,2  204     5,0  18,2  228    
Spacetel Guinea-Bissau S.A.  2,5  13,6  322     3,0  13,7  321    
Other        416           711    
Total        16 638           22 068    

Goodwill is tested annually for impairment. The recoverable amounts of CGUs were determined based on value in use calculations. The calculations mainly used cash flow projections based on financial budgets approved by management covering a three to five-year (2016: three to 10-year) period. Management is confident that projections covering periods longer than three years (MTN Yemen) (2016: MTN Syria (JSC) and MTN Sudan Company Limited) are appropriate in order for terminal values to be determined using steady state cash flows. Cash flows beyond the above period were extrapolated using the estimated growth rates as mentioned above. These growth rates are in line with industry norms.

The following key assumptions were used for the value in use calculations:

  • Growth rates: the group used steady growth rates to extrapolate revenues beyond the budget period cash flows. The growth rates were consistent with publicly available information relating to long-term average growth rates for each of the markets in which the respective CGU operated. The average growth rates used ranged from 2% to 15,0% (2016: 1,9% to 15,0%); and
  • Discount rates: discount rates ranged from 9,7% to 41,9% (2016: 9,5% to 35,5%). Discount rates used reflect both time value of money and other specific risks relating to the relevant CGU.

Goodwill impairment

Impairment losses were recognised relating to the following entities:

   Impairment losses      Recoverable amount1    
   2017 
Rm 
2016 
Rm 
   2017 
Rm 
2016 
Rm 
  
MTN Afghanistan  841  –     2 317  –    
MTN Yemen  807  –     1 769  –    
MTN Sudan Company Limited  983  –     2 963  6 117    
MTN Syria (JSC) –  269     2 888  3 426    
Areeba Guinea S.A. (Conakry) –  402     –  578    
Afrihost Proprietary Limited  –  202     –  325    
   2 631  873     9 937  10 446    

1 This includes any minority portion of the recoverable amount of the CGU.

In a number of the group’s operations in the MENA region the socio-political instability experienced in these markets resulted in suppressed revenue growth and lower operating margins in the current year, resulting in decreased forecast cash flows at 30 June 2017. This necessitated impairment reviews being performed on the group’s operations in Guinea-Bissau, Guinea-Conakry, Liberia, Ghana, Afghanistan, Sudan, Yemen and Syria where the carrying amounts of these cash-generating units were compared to their respective recoverable amounts.

The goodwill of MTN Syria and MTN Sudan was fully impaired as at 31 December 2016 and 30 June 2017, respectively. The remaining goodwill in MTN Afghanistan and MTN Yemen amount to R490 million and R1 202 million at 31 December 2017, respectively.

The group performed the annual impairment assessments on all goodwill balances at 31 December 2017 and have not identified any further impairments at that date.

Areeba Guinea S.A. (Conakry)

During 2016, Areeba Guinea S.A. (Conakry) experienced a decline in EBITDA and Guinea-Conakry experienced poor economic performance countrywide. Consequently, a review of the recoverable amount of Conakry was undertaken subsequent to which an impairment loss was recognised. The recognition of the impairment loss resulted in the goodwill for Conakry being fully impaired.

Afrihost Proprietary Limited

Based on an agreement concluded by the group to sell its 50,02% investment in Afrihost Proprietary Limited (Afrihost) for R325 million, a goodwill impairment loss was recognised at 30 June 2016 on the remeasurement of assets to fair value less costs to sell in accordance with IFRS 5 Non-current Assets Held for Sale and Discontinued Operations. The investment was disposed of in 2016.

Recoverable amounts are represented by a CGU’s value in use. A specific change in the discount and growth rates (see below) would result in the recoverable amount being equal to the carrying amount of the net assets of the following CGUs:

   2017     2016    
   Change to 
discount 
rate 
% 
Change to 
growth 
rate 
% 
   Change to 
discount 
rate 
% 
Change to 
growth 
rate 
% 
  
MTN Afghanistan  5,25  (1,50)    –  –    
MTN Liberia  3,45  (3,10)    –  –    
MTN Sudan Company Limited  –  –     10,89  (1,79)   
MTN Yemen  *  *     6,34  (0,54)   
1 A minimal change in the discount and growth rates at 31 December 2017 would result in the recoverable amount being equal to the carrying amount of the net assets of MTN Yemen.
5.2.2

Encumbrances

Borrowings are secured by intangible assets of Scancom Limited (MTN Ghana) with a carrying amount of R934 million (2016: R1 083 million) (note 6.1).

5.2.3

Licences

Licence agreements Type  Granted/
renewed 
Term    
Mobile Telephone Networks Proprietary Limited (South Africa) ECS licence  15/01/2009  15 years    
  ECNS licence  15/01/2009  20 years    
   900MHz  29/01/2003  Renewable annually    
   1 800MHz  29/10/2004  Renewable annually    
   2 100MHz  02/02/2005  Renewable annually    
   6GHz  14/06/2010  Renewable annually    
   7GHz  14/06/2010  Renewable annually    
   8GHz  14/06/2010  Renewable annually    
   10,5GHz  07/02/2006  Renewable annually    
   11GHz  23/03/2009  Renewable annually    
   13GHz  06/04/2009  Renewable annually    
   15GHz  21/10/2005  Renewable annually    
   18GHz  14/06/2010  Renewable annually    
   23GHz  14/06/2010  Renewable annually    
   26GHz Sub 17  21/10/2005  Renewable annually    
   26GHz Sub 18  07/02/2006  Renewable annually    
   28GHz  12/04/2012  Renewable annually    
   38GHz  07/10/2005  Renewable annually    
MTN Uganda Limited  900MHz  15/04/1998  20 years    
   1 800MHz  15/04/1998  20 years    
MTN Rwandacell Limited  GSM  01/07/2008  13 years    
   SNO  30/06/2006  15 years    
MTN Zambia Limited  National service licence  31/08/2010  15 years    
   International network licence  31/08/2010  15 years    
MTN Nigeria Communications Limited  1 800MHz  03/11/2015  5 years    
   900MHz  03/11/2015  5 years    
   3G spectrum licence  01/05/2007  15 years    
   Unified access licence (including international gateway) 01/09/2006  15 years    
   WACS  01/01/2010  20 years    
   WiMax 3,5GHz spectrum  2007  Renewable annually    
   Microwave spectrum 8GHz – 26GHz  2001  Renewable annually    
   Digital terrestrial TV broadcasting licence  12/08/2015  10 years    
   800MHz spectrum (Visafone) 01/01/2015  10 years    
   2,6GHz spectrum  01/08/2016  10 years    
   Unified access1 service licence (Visafone) 01/07/2007  10 years    
1 The unified access service licence (Visafone) has expired and renewal of the licence is under discussion. 

Licence agreements Type  Granted/
renewed 
Term    
Scancom Limited (MTN Ghana) 900MHz  02/12/2004  15 years    
   1 800MHz  02/12/2004  15 years    
   3G  23/01/2009  15 years    
   Fixed access service of unified access  06/07/2015  4 years    
   International gateway  08/11/2014  5 years    
   4G (LTE) spectrum  01/06/2016  15 years    
Mobile Telephone Networks Cameroon Limited  2G  15/02/2015  15 years    
   3G  15/02/2015  15 years    
   4G  15/02/2015  15 years    
MTN Côte d’Ivoire S.A.1  3G/UMTS 1,9/2,1GHz  31/05/2012  10 years    
   Universal networks  04/01/2016  17 years    
Spacetel Benin S.A.  900MHz  19/10/2007  25 years    
   1 800MHz  19/10/2007  25 years    
   Universal licence  10/08/2012  20 years    
Areeba Guinea S.A.  900MHz  31/08/2005  18 years    
   1 800MHz  31/08/2005  18 years    
   3G  14/08/2013  10 years    
   WiMax  04/08/2014  5 years    
MTN Congo S.A.  900MHz  25/11/2011  15 years    
   1 800MHz  25/11/2011  15 years    
   Optical fibre licence  02/04/2010  15 years    
   3G  25/11/2011  17 years    
   2G  25/11/2011  15 years    
   International gateway by optical fibre  03/06/2013  10 years    
   LTE spectrum  09/12/2016  15 years    
Lonestar Communications Corporation LLC (Liberia) Universal telecommunication licence (Novafone) 04/08/2015  15 years    
   WiMax  24/03/2009  15 years    
   3G  19/02/2013  10 years    
Spacetel Guinea-Bissau S.A.  900MHz  23/05/2014  10 years    
   1 800MHz  23/05/2014  10 years    
   3G  17/07/2015  10 years    
   4G  17/07/2015  10 years    
MTN Syria (JSC) Freehold licence2 01/01/2015  20 years    
   900MHz  01/01/2016  19 years    
   1 800MHz  01/01/2016  19 years    
   2 000MHz  01/01/2016  19 years    
   Additional frequency 1 800MHz  07/01/2017  17,5 years    
1 The WiMax 2,5GHz – 3,5GHz licence became obsolete (no longer in use) and was derecognised in 2016.
2 The 900MHz, 1 800MHz and 3G licences from 2015 were replaced during the prior year upon termination of the BOT arrangement and entering into a freehold arrangement.

Licence agreements Type  Granted/
renewed 
Term    
MTN Sudan Company Limited  2G +3G  25/10/2003  20 years    
   Transmission  25/10/2003  20 years    
   VSAT gateway  25/10/2003  20 years    
   VSAT hub  25/10/2003  20 years    
   VSAT terminal  25/10/2003  20 years    
   Frequency 4G  25/10/2017  7 years    
MTN Afghanistan Limited  3G unified licence  01/07/2012  15 years    
   New number range RTU  31/10/2012  15 years    
   New number range RTU  25/08/2013  14 years    
   New number range RTU  31/10/2014  13 years    
   New number range RTU  31/05/2015  12 years    
MTN Yemen  900MHz1 01/08/2015  2 years and 5 months    
   1 800MHz1 01/08/2015  2 years and 5 months    
MTN Cyprus Limited  900MHz  01/12/2003  20 years    
   1 800MHz  01/12/2003  20 years    
   4G (LTE) 2 100MHz  01/12/2003  20 years    
   800MHz  05/09/2016  12 years    
   2 600MHz  05/09/2016  12 years    
1 These licences expired during the year and are still under negotiation for renewal.

Notes to the group financial statements l Note 5.2