MTN Group’s performance for the six months
ended 30 June 2009 was satisfactory considering
the economic downturn which affected markets
worldwide. Reported revenue and EBITDA results,
when compared to the prior six month period
ended 30 June, were not materially impacted
by movements in currencies in the majority of
countries in which we operate against the ZAR.
However, growth in earnings were negatively
impacted by functional currency losses of
R2,8 billion (June 2008: R0,9 million gain) on
shareholder loans, receivables and cash.
Although competition increased in most markets
following the entry of new competitors, execution
of the operational strategy has generally proved
successful. MTN’s network expansion and capacity
investment strategy initiated in 2008 has also
supported the strong performance of the Group’s
subsidiaries, particularly where competitors have
elected to scale back on investments. Enhanced
distribution channels and attractive value
propositions also contributed to the positive
performance.
The Group’s mobile subscriber base passed the
100 million milestone during the reported period
to reach 103,2 million subscribers at 30 June 2009.
This is a 14% increase since 31 December 2008 and
was mainly driven by robust subscriber growth
in MTN Nigeria and MTN Irancell which added
4,3 million and 3,1 million subscribers respectively
for the half year. Subscribers have increased by 39%
since 30 June 2008.
The Group reports its performance by region,
namely South and East Africa (SEA), West and
Central Africa (WECA) and the Middle East and
North Africa (MENA). MTN consolidates 49% of
MTN Irancell’s financials.
Income statement analysis
MTN Group revenues increased by 24,2% to
R57,3 billion (30 June 2008: R46,1 billion), largely
driven by the strong growth in subscribers since
30 June 2008.
The WECA region remains the largest contributor to
Group revenue, contributing 47% of total revenue,
up 1 percentage point compared with the sixmonth
period to 30 June 2008. The SEA and MENA
regions contributed 34% and 19% respectively of
the Group’s total revenues.
US dollar-reported average revenue per user
(ARPU) declined considerably from the 30 June
2008 comparative in most operations due to
increased penetration and the depreciation of
local currencies against the US dollar. ARPU’s are
also lower than in December 2008 but in line with
the ARPU for the first quarter. Slowing GDP growth,
increased penetration into lower-use segments of
the market and aggressive competition also had a
negative impact on local-currency ARPU’s.
In line with the strong growth in revenue, MTN’s
earnings before interest, tax, depreciation and
amortisation (EBITDA) increased by 24,8% to
R24,5 billion for the six-month period ended
30 June 2009 (June 2008: R19,6 billion). Cost
optimisation and other efficiencies, although
partially offset by higher network operating
costs and inflationary increases on staffing, drove
margins slightly higher.
The WECA region recorded 33% EBITDA growth to
R14,8 billion (June 2008: R11,2 billion), contributing
61% to the Group’s total EBITDA. The SEA region’s
contribution of 25% based on a 6% growth to
R6,2 billion (June 2008: R5,9 billion), was affected
by increased operating expenditure partly due to the integration of newly acquired businesses
in MTN South Africa and pricing pressure
from new competition in Rwanda. The MENA
region grew EBITDA by 34% to R2,9 billion
(June 2008: R2,2 billion) and contributed 12%
to Group EBITDA, increasing its contribution by
1 percentage point compared with the prior year.
The Group’s EBITDA margin remained relatively
stable at 42,8%, compared with 42,6% for the six
months to 30 June 2008.
The Group incurred capital expenditure (capex) of
R15,5 billion for the half year, a 50% increase over
June 2008. We anticipate that while a substantial
portion of the approved capex has been
committed as part of our expansion strategy, some
investments are only likely to be capitalised in the
first half of 2010.
The Group’s depreciation charge increased by
R1,6 billion to R5,9 billion (June 2008: R4,4 billion)
following the substantial increase in network
capital expansion projects initiated in 2008. Nigeria,
Iran and South Africa were the main contributors
to the increase in depreciation, adding R0,5 billion,
R0,3 billion and R0,2 billion respectively. The Group amortisation charge was in line with the prior
comparative period.
Net finance costs increased by 143% to R3,6 billion
compared to the same period last year. The large
increase is due to the R2,8 billion (June 2008:
R0,9 billion gain) functional currency loss in
Mauritius which arises on the translation of
US dollar-denominated loans, receivables and
cash balances. The Nigeria put option charge
to income was a credit of R1 billion (June 2008:
R0,9 billion debit) mostly due to the devaluation of
the Naira versus the ZAR.
The Group taxation charge decreased by 18%
(R1,0 billion) to R4,5 billion (June 2008: R5,5 billion).
The decrease is mainly attributable to the full effect
of the Nigerian commencement provisions having
been absorbed in the reporting period ended 30
June 2008 which decrease is partially offset by
additional withholding tax on dividends from
Nigeria that are sourced from post Pioneer profits.
The Group’s effective tax rate reduced from 44%
in June 2008 to 33% in June 2009. The period-toperiod
decrease in the effective rate is also in part
attributable to the Nigerian put option effect on
the profit before tax.
Group basic earnings per share (EPS) increased
by 22,4% to 409,7 cents per share compared to
30 June 2008. Adjusted headline EPS decreased
to 363,8 cents, 10.9% lower than at 30 June 2008.
The various contributory factors, both positive
and negative, that resulted in the net decrease
in adjusted headline EPS are the impact of the
reversal of the put option, the impact of functional
currency profits in the prior comparative period
versus functional currency losses in the current
period as well as the lower effective tax rate.
The Group continues to report adjusted headline
EPS in addition to basic headline EPS. The
adjustment is in respect of the IFRS requirement
that the Group accounts for a written put option
held by a minority shareholder of one of the
Group subsidiaries, which provides the minority
shareholder the right to require the subsidiary or
its holding company to acquire this shareholding
at fair value. Although the Group has complied
with the requirements, the board of directors (the
board) has reservations about the appropriateness of this treatment and hence the adjustment.
The net impact is that adjusted headline reflect
the decrease of EPS of 51,7 cents (June 2008:
69,2 cents, including the impact of the reversal of
the deferred tax asset).
Balance sheet and cash flow analysis
MTN Group’s assets decreased by 14% to
R146 billion compared with R170 billion at
31 December 2008. This was largely as a result of the
depreciation of the closing rate of the respective
local currencies against the ZAR.
Asset classes affected by this include property,
plant and equipment which decreased by 5% from
R64,2 billion to R61,0 billion notwithstanding
additions of R15,0 billion; goodwill and intangible
assets which decreased by 18% (R8.1 billion)
to R37,6 billion compared to December 2008;
and current assets which decreased by 24%
(R13,3 billion) to R41,4 billion from December 2008.
Cash generated from operating activities
improved from R13,0 billion for the 6 months to
30 June 2008 to R17,0 billion reflecting the strong
operational performance after paying a dividend of
R3,4 billion (June 2008: R2,5 billion). Cash outflows
from investing activities utilised R16,9 billion of cash
as a result of the significant capital expenditure
programme. The foreign currency translation
losses of R3,9 billion contributed to the net debt
increasing to R15,2 billion from R12,9 billion.
Other
Acquisitions in the six-month period ended
30 June 2009 included 100% of Verizon South
Africa (Pty) Ltd (Verizon) in February 2009 and 59%
of i-Talk Cellular (Pty) Ltd (iTalk) in January 2009. The
acquisition of Verizon is expected to improve MTN
South Africa’s competitive position in the rapidly
converging mobile/ISP sector, particularly in the
corporate segment. Verizon is currently being
integrated within MTN Business, including the
previously acquired Network Solutions, to allow
for a comprehensive and integrated offer to our
customer base. Verizon has been reported under
“other” in the SEA region for the review period.
Changes to shareholding for the six months ended
30 June 2009 include a 2,2% sale of equity interest
in MTN Zambia to Zambian financial institutions
by way of a private placement as part of MTN’s
undertaking to broaden its local shareholder base
and fulfil its licence commitment.
MTN purchased the entire issued ordinary share
capital of Newshelf 664 (Pty) Ltd (Newshelf ) in
May 2009. The Newshelf acquisition was effected
by way of a specific issue of 213.9 million MTN
shares to the PIC and the specific repurchase by
MTN of 243,5 million MTN shares. MTN acquired the
Newshelf shares at an effective discount to market
value and intends to apply a significant portion
of this effective discount to facilitate a new Black
Economic Empowerment (BEE) transaction. The
board remains fully committed to implementing
a BEE transaction as soon as conditions become
conducive.
Operational review
South Africa MTN South Africa’s subscriber
base grew by 62 000 during the review period
to 17,2 million. The disappointing increase in
subscribers was due to a combination of factors
including challenges on the network and
supporting systems, slowing GDP growth, pressure on consumer spend, and competitor activity in the
first half of the year.
Postpaid subscribers grew by 4% to 2,9 million for
the six-month period. The postpaid market has had
a challenging six months with economic pressure
affecting growth in the market and generally
putting a squeeze on credit. Growth was mainly
attributable to MTN Anytime, which currently
makes up 39% of the postpaid base.
The prepaid subscriber base declined by
52 000 during the period. ARPU in the prepaid
and postpaid market segments declined by 5% to
R92 and 10% to R362 respectively.
The proposed Musica transaction has been
terminated as certain legal conditions precedent,
beyond the control of the parties, could not be
met.
The iTalk acquisition was finalised in January 2009.
The branded channel incorporates eight stores
that will ultimately be integrated under the MTN
Brand. MTN South Africa will maintain its focus on
distribution.
MTN South Africa also continues to invest in
its network (radio, core and transmission). The
Gauteng southern fibre network ring to
interconnect the main switching and data centers
has been completed. Further trenching is under
way to complete the Gauteng northern ring
which incorporates Pretoria. The 5 000km national
fibre optic network tri-build agreement has been
finalised. The trenching route between Gauteng
and the Durban route has begun. The operation
has rolled out 234 second-generation (2G) and
307 third-generation (3G) base transceiver stations
(BTS’s) since the beginning of 2009, enabling it
to increase circuit switch data capacity by 8,5%
and packet switch data capacity by 80%. The
3G population coverage increased from 35% in
December 2008 to 44% at the half year.
Nigeria MTN Nigeria subscribers grew by
19% over the six months to 27.3 million at June
2009. MTN Nigeria recorded strong growth in
the first half and improved market share to 48%.
Significant investment in network capacity and
improved quality of service strategies adopted in
2008 and 2009 gave MTN Nigeria an advantage
over its competitors for the period. The operation
successfully restructured its sales and distribution
strategy to improve the focus of the dealer channel
and drive acquisitions.
APRU declined by USD4 from December 2008
to USD12. Although the USD ARPU shows a
considerable decline following the depreciation of
the Naira against the US dollar, local-currency ARPU
declined at a slower rate and in line with increased
penetration in lower-use segments.
Aggressive network rollout continued in the first
half of 2009, as MTN Nigeria rolled out 426 2G and
236 3G BTS’s. The 3G rollout is gaining momentum
with 787 3G BTS’s now live and the completion
of phase 2 of the 3G rollout underway. A further
1 548km of transmission expansion to improve the
network is in progress (66.42% complete).
Ghana MTN Ghana increased subscribers
by 12% over the six months to 7,2 million at
30 June 2009. Market share only reduced slightly
from 55% to 54% over the period despite fierce
competition from new market entrants. The launch
of a loyalty programme, Rally Around the Flag, and
the continued success of MTN Zone assisted with
subscriber retention.
ARPU decreased by 33% from USD12 to USD8 mostly
due to the devaluation of the Cedi against the
US dollar. Local-currency ARPU decreased by 15% after aggressive price offers by new competitors
and deeper penetration into the market.
MTN Ghana rolled out 289 BTS’s for the six-month
period.
Irancell MTN Irancell increased its subscriber
base by 20% over the six month period to
19,2 million at June 2009 through continued
promotional campaigns. An enhanced distribution
channel that included efficient subscriber
registration has also contributed to subscriber
growth.
ARPU dropped USD1 to USD8 mainly due to
increased penetration into lower-use market
segments.
MTN Irancell added 793 BTSs for the period,
improving quality and capacity on the network.
During the six months, 368 more cities and an
additional 1 434km of road have been covered.
Network coverage of the population increased
from 62% at the beginning of the year to 67% at
June 2009. WiMax rollout is successfully on track
with pilot sites identified, call centres set up and
dealers selected.
Syria MTN Syria added 11 000 subscribers to
its base in the six month period. The low growth
in subscriber numbers was, however, in line with
lower demand in the telecoms sector in the country
with no loss of market share. Segmental product
offerings and churn management initiatives have
been put in place to drive new acquisitions.
Subscriber ARPU declined marginally from USD19
in December 2008 to USD18 in June 2009.
The implementation of planned network
expansions and upgrades has decreased
congestion and improved radio capacity.
MTN Syria has added 74 BTS’s during the period.
Limited 3G service was commercially launched
in January 2009, offering attractive data bundles.
Proposed transaction with Bharti
On 25 May 2009, MTN Group and Bharti Airtel
Limited (Bharti) announced they were exploring
a potential transaction in which MTN and its
shareholders would acquire, pursuant to a
scheme of arrangement, an approximate 36%
economic interest in Bharti, of which 25%
would be held by MTN with the remainder held directly by MTN shareholders, and Bharti would
acquire an approximate 49% shareholding
in MTN.
The potential transaction between Bharti and
MTN would create a leading telecommunication
service provider group, aligning Bharti’s marketleading
Indian business with MTN’s marketleading
African and Middle Eastern operations.
The potential transaction would also represent
a significant development in south-south
cooperation between India and South Africa.
The rationale for the transaction is compelling and
includes diversification and synergistic benefits
as well as addressing the objective of becoming
one of the pre-eminent emerging-market
telecommunications companies.
The exclusivity period has been extended to 30
September 2009. No decision or agreement to
acquire any shares or Global Depository Receipt’s
or implement the potential transaction outlined
above has yet been made by the boards of either
MTN or Bharti. Shareholders will be advised of any
further developments.
Prospects
There are some indications that global economic
conditions may be starting a slow recovery
although many of our markets remain relatively
vulnerable at present. Competition across MTN’s
footprint is likely to continue to increase. Shorter
term prospects in South Africa remain challenging,
compounded by the impact of new subscriber
registration requirements from 1 August 2009. MTN
remains focused on:
- actively seeking value-accretive expansion
opportunities in emerging markets;
- tightly monitoring infrastructure investments to
ensure appropriate levels of capacity and quality
of service for an enlarged market;
- optimising efficiencies in maintaining and
improving our competitive position while
ensuring the Group is able to benefit from a
rapidly converging technology market, and
continued investment in sub-marine cables for
efficient access;
- continuing engagement with regulatory
authorities in the development and refinement of
the telecommunication sector; and
- the implementation of MTN’s proposed BEE deal
at the appropriate time.
Revised subscriber net addition guidance
| Net additions for December 2009 |
|
| South Africa |
500 |
| Nigeria |
7 400 |
| Ghana |
1 400 |
| Iran |
6 000 |
| Syria |
400 |
| Rest |
6 900 |
| Total |
22 600 |
For and on behalf of the Board
M C Ramaphosa
(Chairman)
P F Nhleko
(Group President and CEO)
Fairland
27 August 2009
Certain statements in this announcement that are
neither reported financial results nor other historical
information are forward-looking statements, relating
to matters such as future earnings, savings, synergies,
events, trends, plans or objectives.
Undue reliance should not be placed on such
statements because they are inherently subject to
known and unknown risks and uncertainties and can
be affected by other factors that could cause actual
results and company plans and objectives to differ
materially from those expressed or implied in the
forward-looking statements (or from past results).
Unfortunately, the company cannot undertake to
publicly update or revise any of these forward-looking
statements, whether to reflect new information of
future events or circumstances or otherwise. |