Home | Book 1 - MTN Group Overview | Downloads | Glossary of terms |
 
 
Report of the audit committee
Report of the independent auditors
Certificate of the company secretary
Director’s report
Principal accounting policies
Group income statement
Group balance sheet
Group statement of changes in equity
Group cash flow statement
Notes to the Group financial statements
Company income statement
Company balance sheet
Company statement of changes in equity
Company cash flow statement
Notes to the company financial statements
Annexure 1: Interest in subsidiary companies and joint ventures
Annexure 2: Group’s attributable interest in associated companies

Directors’ report

for the year ended 31 December 2008

The directors have pleasure in submitting their report on the annual financial statements of the Group for the year ended 31 December 2008.

Nature of business

MTN Group Limited (MTN Group or the Company) carries on the business of investing in the telecommunications industry through its subsidiary companies, joint ventures and associate companies.

Review of financial results and operations

The detailed reviews of financial results and the activities of MTN Group are contained in the reports of the chairman, the Group president and CEO, the Group finance director, the Group chief operating officer and the annual financial statements.

      31 December   31 December  
      2008   2007  
      Rm   Rm  
  Aggregate net profits in: Subsidiaries   15 626   13 259  
  Joint ventures   511   134  
  Associated companies     8  
      16 137   13 401  
             
  Aggregate net losses in:          
  Subsidiaries   (822)   (2 111)  
  Joint ventures     (682)  
      (822)   (2 793)  

Subsidiary companies

Details of entities in which MTN Group has a direct or indirect interest are set out in Annexures 1 and Annexures 2, of the financial statements.

All the Group subsidiaries have a year-end consistent with that of the MTN Group, with the exception of MTN Irancell, which has a year-end of 19 March, due to statutory requirements in Iran.

Distribution to shareholders

A dividend of 181 cents per share (December 2007: 136 cents per share) amounting to R3,381 million (December 2007: R2,536 million) in respect of the financial year ended 31 December 2008 was declared on Wednesday, 11 March 2009, payable to shareholders registered on Friday, 27 March 2009. The payments of future dividends will depend on the board‘s ongoing assessment of MTN Group’s earnings, financial position, including its cash needs, future earnings prospects and other factors.

Shareholders on the South African register who dematerialised their ordinary shares receive payment of their dividends electronically, as provided for by STRATE. For those shareholders who have not yet dematerialised their shareholding in the Company in certificated form, please note that the Company operates an electronic funds transmission service, whereby dividends may be electronically transferred to shareholders‘ bank accounts. These shareholders are encouraged to mandate this method of payment for all future dividends, by approaching our share registrar, Computershare Investor Services (Proprietary) Limited, whose contact details are reflected in shareholders‘ information.

Share capital

Authorised share capital

There was no change in the authorised share capital of the Company during the year under review. The authorised share capital of MTN Group is 2,5 billion ordinary shares of 0,01 cent each. The movement in the issued ordinary share capital during the year under review is reflected below.

Issued share capital

The issued share capital of the company was increased during the year by the allotment and issue of shares to employees who exercised share options in terms of the MTN Group Limited Share Option Scheme. The allotments were as follows:

     
  Shares Strike price
  2 596 055 at R9,31
  75 660 at R13,53
  449 970 at R27,00
  90 812 at R40,50

Accordingly, at 31 December 2008, the issued share capital of the Company was R186 801 (December 2007: R186 480) comprising 1 868 010 304 (December 2007: 1 864 797 807) ordinary shares of 0,01 cent each. No treasury shares were held at the date of this report.

Control of unissued share capital

The unissued ordinary shares are the subject of a general authority granted to the directors in terms of section 221 of the Companies Act, 1973 as amended (Act no 61 of 1973) (the Companies Act). As this general authority remains valid only until the next annual general meeting, which is to be held on 24 June 2009, members will be asked at that meeting to consider an ordinary resolution placing the said unissued ordinary shares up to a maximum of 10% of the Company’s issued share capital under the control of the directors until the next annual general meeting.

Further details of the authorised and issued ordinary shares as well as the share premium for the year ended 31 December 2008 appear in note 15 to the MTN Group annual financial statements.

Acquisition of the Company’s own shares

At the last annual general meeting held on 19 June 2008, shareholders gave the Company or any of its subsidiaries, a general approval in terms of sections 85 and 89 of the Companies Act, by way of special resolution, for the acquisition of its own shares. As this general approval remains valid only until the next annual general meeting, which is to be held on 24 June 2009, members will be asked at that meeting to consider a special resolution to renew this general approval until the next annual general meeting.

The Company did not exercise the approval to buy back shares during the year under review.

Shareholders‘ interest

Major shareholders

The following information was extracted from the Company‘s share register at 31 December 2008:

      31 December 2008   31 December 2007
  Nominees holding shares in excess of 5% of the issued ordinary   Number of   % of issued     Number of   % of issued  
  share capital of the Company:   shares   share capital     shares   share capital  
                       
  Nedcor Bank Nominees Limited   756 664 535   40,51     686 542 027   36,82  
  Standard Bank Nominees (Tvl) (Proprietary) Limited   632 349 026   33,85     575 585 098   30,87  
  First National Nominees (Proprietary) Limited   304 791 742   16,32     308 704 138   16,55  
  Spread of ordinary shareholders                    
  Public   1 396 012 143   74,73     1 437 498 643   77,09  
  Non-public   471 998 161   25,27     427 299 164   22,91  
  – Directors of MTN Group Limited and major subsidiaries   4 023 540   0,22     645 089   0,03  
  – MTN Uganda Staff Provident Fund         1 500    
  – Lombard Odier Darier Hentsch &Cie (M1 Limited)   190 084 630   10,18     183 152 564   9,82  
  – Newshelf 664 (Proprietary) Limited   277 889 991   14,87     243 500 011   13,06  
                       
  Total issued share capital   1 868 010 304   100,00     1 864 797 807   100,00  

Disclosures in accordance with section 140A (8) (a) of the Companies Act and paragraph 8.63 of the JSE Listings Requirements

According to information received by the directors, the following shareholders held shares in excess of 5% of the issued ordinary share capital of the Company:

      31 December 2008   31 December 2007  
      Number of   % of issued     Number of   % of issued  
  Beneficial shareholders holding 5% or more   shares   share capital     shares   share capital  
                       
  Public Investment Corporation   219 002 091   11,17     247 425 249   13,27  
  Newshelf 664 (Proprietary) Limited*   277 889 991   14,87     243 500 011   13,06  
  Lombard Odier Darier Hentsch & Cie (M1 Limited)   190 084 630   10,18     183 152 564   9,82  

*Further details of the Newshelf 664 shareholding are provided in the Director`s report.

Certain of these shareholdings are partially or wholly included in the nominee companies reflected in the preceding table. Apart from this, the Company is not aware of any other party who has a shareholding of 5% or more in the Company.

Reward and remuneration philosophy

The principles of MTN Group's remuneration policy reflect the Group's objectives of a sound governance process and long-term value creation for the Group's shareholders. Also it is designed to support key business strategies and create a strong, performance-orientated environment. At the same time the policy must attract, motivate and retain talent.

Performance management

The performance of MTN employees is greatly enhanced through an effective performance management system at all levels of remuneration, whether through the fixed guaranteed package, or the various short-term and long-term incentive schemes.

As a multi-national company, all applicable employees and executives within the MTN Group of companies and operating units participate in the Group's Integrated Performance Framework (IPF) by means of performance agreements, thereby ensuring that the entire group is fully aligned in achieving the strategic objectives and goals as determined by the board. This process consists of two elements, namely the individual performance section, which rewards individuals for achieving their individual targets through the salary increase process; and the team performance section which rewards the team for achieving the strategically determined value drivers, coupled with the company's performance targets, and is rewarded through the performance bonus incentive scheme.

The MTN Group board of directors has delegated responsibility for remuneration policy to the nomination, remuneration, human resources and corporate governance committee (NRHR & CG committee). The role of this committee, among others, is to establish the overall principles that determine the remuneration of the Group's executive directors and senior management. The full details of the NRHR & CG committee's role, constitution and attendance are outlined in the corporate governance report.

In setting remuneration policy, the NRHR & CG committee recognises the need to be competitive in an international market. The committee's policy is to set remuneration levels which ensure that the executive directors and senior management are fairly and responsibly rewarded for their contribution to the Group's operating and financial performance. Also in order to promote a common interest with shareholders, performance linked share based incentives are considered to be an important element of the executive incentive policy.

Executive directors and senior management

The remuneration of the executive directors and senior management currently consists of three main components, to balance long- and short-term objectives; a base salary, annual bonus plan with performance targets and long-term incentives in the form of share-based incentive schemes. The last two are designed to encourage and reward superior performance, employee retention and to align the interests of the executive directors and senior management as closely as possible with the interests of shareholders. In addition to these main components, the executive directors and senior management also receive pensions, medical insurance, death/disability insurance and other benefits.

Performance bonuses for executive directors are linked to operational and financial value drivers pertaining to business performance against budget for individual operations and the MTN Group as a whole. These value drivers are determined by the board every year in respect of the next financial year. Each executive director's performance bonus is conditional upon achievement of their specific value drivers and key performance indicators which are structured to retain a balance between the performance of entities for which they are directly responsible, and that of the Group. In order to align incentive awards with the performance to which they relate, bonuses reflected are for amounts accrued in respect of each year and not the amounts paid in that year. The bonuses are determined by the NRHR & CG committee and are approved by the board.

The base salary of executive directors is subject to annual review and is set with reference to external market benchmarks, taking individuals into consideration. Executive directors do not receive payment of directors' fees or committee fees in respect of meetings attended.

MTN Group recognises the benefit that the involvement of the executive directors as non-executive directors of other companies (under certain conditions) has to the individual and to the company. however, each director is normally permitted to accept only one outside appointment. The directors' fees in that regard are ceded to MTN Group.

The total benefits received by executive directors are reflected in the following tables:

Remuneration of non-executive directors

MTN Group's non-executive directors receive annual retainer and meeting attendance fees. they do not participate in any type of share incentive scheme or receive pension-related benefits.

The non-executive directors' remuneration has been unchanged since the AGM held in June 2006. It is important to ensure that the remuneration of non-executive directors remains competitive in order to enable the Company to retain and attract persons of the required calibre in order to make meaningful contributions to the Company. Given its global footprint and growth rate and having regard to the appropriate capabilities, skills and experience required, the Group president and CEO, in consultation with the Group executive for human resources and Group financial director, conducted a review of the remuneration paid to non-executive directors, based on data provided by independent remuneration specialists and benchmarked against comparable international South African companies. The results indicated that the current remuneration paid was materially below that of comparable entities. The NRHR & CG committee debated and considered the revised remuneration proposal at length and after reaching consensus, recommended the revised remuneration proposal to the board, which sanctioned the proposal for recommendation to shareholders at the annual general meeting to be held on 24 June 2009. The proposed new fees structure is outlined in the notice of the fourteenth annual general meeting, and will have retrospective effect to 1 January 2008.

The fees received by executive and non-executive directors during 2008 are reflected in the following table:

        Directors‘     Retirement Other     Share    
      Date fees   Salaries benefits benefits   Bonuses options Total  
      appointed R000   R000 R000 R000   R000 R000 R000  
  Executive directors                        
  PF Nhleko   01/06/01     6 498 385 75   13 000 19 958  
  RD Nisbet   01/10/01     3 090 410 241   5 750 9 491  
  RS Dabengwa   01/10/01     3 771 483 553   6 250 12 585 23 642  
  Sub-total         13 359 1 278 869   25 000 12 585 53 091  
  Non-executive directors                        
  MC Ramaphosa   01/10/01 820               820  
  DDB Band   01/10/01 575               575  
  K Kalyan**   13/06/06 2 019               2 019  
  AT Mikati**   17/07/06 1 858               1 858  
  MJN Njeke   13/06/06 489               489  
  JHN Strydom   11/03/04 538               538  
  AF van Biljon   01/11/02 580               580  
  J van Rooyen   17/07/06 528               528  
                 
  Directors who resigned during 2008                        
  MA Ramphele   13/06/06 58               58  
  AH Sharbatly**   13/06/06 434               434  
  PL Woicke**   13/06/06 291               291  
  Sub-total     8 190               8 190  
  Total     8 190   13 359 1 278 869   25 000 12 585 61 281  

**The fees are paid in euro but have been converted to rand for the sake of consistency.
†Fees are paid to M1 Limited.

      Directors‘     Retirement Other     Share    
      Date fees   Salaries bene ts bene ts   Bonuses options Total  
      appointed R000   R000 R000 R000   R000 R000 R000  
  Executive directors                        
  PF Nhleko   01/06/01     5 971 514 414   9 358 16 257  
  RD Nisbet   01/10/01     2 943 377 154   3 425 6 899  
  RS Dabengwa   01/10/01     3 472 445 177   3 225 24 200 31 519  
  Sub-total         12 386 1 336 745   16 008 24 200 54 675  
  Non-executive directors                        
  MC Ramaphosa   01/10/01 859               859  
  DDB Band   01/10/01 649               649  
  K Kalyan   13/06/06 1 648               1 648  
  AT Mikati**   17/07/06 2 132               2 132  
  MJN Njeke   13/06/06 680               680  
  M Ramphele   13/06/06 320               320  
  JHN Strydom   11/03/04 617               617  
  AH Sharbatly**   13/06/06 815               815  
  AF van Biljon   01/11/02 736               736  
  J van Rooyen   17/07/06 859               859  
  P Woicke**   13/06/06 1 262               1 262  
  Sub-total     10 577               10 577  
  Total     10 577   12 386 1 336 745   16 008 24 200 65 252  

The MTN Group share options, share appreciation rights and share rights schemes

The Company operates share options, share appreciation rights and share rights schemes (jointly referred to as “the schemes”) and eligible employees, including executive directors, are able to participate in accordance with the schemes’ rules. The schemes are designed to retain and recognise the contributions of executive directors and eligible staff and to provide additional incentives to contribute to the Company’s continuing growth.

In terms of the Company’s share option scheme, the total number of shares which may be allocated for the purposes of the scheme shall not
exceed 5% of the total issued ordinary share capital of the Company, being 81 799 691 shares approved by shareholders in 2001.

The following information is provided in accordance with the provisions of the schemes:

The vesting periods under the schemes are as follows: 20%, 20%, 30% and 30% on the anniversary of the second, third, fourth and fifth years respectively, after the grant date .The strike price is determined as the closing market price for MTN Group Limited shares on the day prior to the date of allocation.

If the options or appreciation rights remain unexercised after a period of 10 years from the date of grant, they lapse. Furthermore, rights are forfeited if the employee leaves the Group before they vest.

Share options
Details of the share options outstanding at year-end are as follows:

      31 December   31 December  
      2008   2007  
      Number of   Number of  
      shares   shares  
  Options allocated and reserved at beginning of year   6 946 726   11 900 904  
  Adjustment to prior year closing balance   5 680   41 140  
      6 952 406   11 942 044  
  Less: Options no longer reserved due to participants leaving the          
  employ of the Group and the lapsing of o ers   (165 240)   (465 010)  
  Less: Options exercised and allotted during the year   (3 212 087)   (4 530 308)  
  Options allocated at year-end   3 575 079   6 946 726  

The options outstanding at the end of the period under review have a weighted average remaining contractual life of four years (December 2007: five years). During the year ended 31 December 2008, no options were granted. The fair values were calculated using the stochastic model. The inputs into the model are reflected below:

    31 December   31 December  
    2008   2007  
Weighted average share price for the year   R120,36   R103,47  
Weighted average exercise price   R100,72   R118,10  
Expected life   3 – 5 years   4 – 6 years  
Risk-free rate   6,77% – 7,60%   8,94% – 10,04%  
Expected dividend yield   0,97%   1,11%  
Expected volatility   40,39% – 46,52%   32,91% – 34,35%  

Expected volatility was determined by calculating the historical volatility of the Company’s share price over the previous six years. The expected life used in the model has been adjusted, based on management’s best estimate, for the effects of non-transferability, exercise restrictions and behavioural considerations. The expected dividend yield was determined based on historical data.

Options exercised during the year yielded the following proceeds, after transaction costs:

      31 December   31 December  
      2008   2007  
      R000   R000  
  Ordinary share capital – at par   *   *  
  Share premium   41 021   60 181  
  Proceeds   41 021   60 181  
  Fair value, at exercise date, of shares issued   339 947   535 032  
*Amount less than R1 million.


The balances of share options, including executive director’s allocations in issue, are reflected below:

          Number out-           Number out-   Remaining  
      Strike   standing at   Forfeited   Exercised   standing at   contractual  
      price   31 December   during   during   31 December   life  
  Offer date   R   2007   2008   2008   2008   (Years)  
  28 September 2001   13,53   599 694   40 150   75 660   483 884   2,74  
  2 September 2002   9,31   4 008 500   35 600   2 595 645   1 377 255   3,67  
  2 January 2003   12,88   119 820       119 820   4,00  
  7 July 2003   16,81   550 000       550 000   4,51  
  1 December 2003   27,00   955 676   25 230   449 970   480 476   4,91  
  1 December 2004   40,50   718 716   64 260   90 812   563 644   5,92  
          6 952 406   165 240   3 212 087   3 575 079      

MTN Group share appreciation rights scheme and share rights scheme (“the rights schemes”)

The share appreciation rights scheme was implemented on 31 May 2006, and superseded the share option scheme.

On 26 August 2008, the board approved the share rights scheme, which superseded the share appreciation rights scheme in respect of future grants. Both the rights schemes operate under the same provisions with the exception that the share rights scheme was extended to allow participation by junior managers.

Share rights under the rights schemes are granted to eligible employees by the relevant employer subsidiary company. Exercised rights are equity settled whereby the relevant MTN Group subsidiary purchases the required MTN shares in the open market.

The balances of the share rights schemes, including executive director's allocations in issue, are reflected below:

          Number out-               Number out-   Remaining  
      Strike   standing at   Offered   Forfeited   Exercised   standing at   contractual  
      price   31 December   during   during   during   31 December   life  
  Offer date   R   2007   2008   2008   2008   2008   (Years)  
  31 May 2006   56,83   433 400     10 700   83 540   339 160   7,41  
  31 May 2006#   56,83   2 028 440     177 420   175 380   1 675 640   6,90  
  21 November 2006   71,00   3 560 300     281 100   300 380   2 978 820   7,89  
  1 January 2007   85,30   104 600         104 600   8,00  
  2 April 2007   98,50   23 700         23 700   8,25  
  22 June 2007   96,00   786 300     58 500     727 800   8,47  
  19 March 2008   126,99     567 800   18 300     549 500   9,21  
  1 September 2008   118,64     2 497 300   52 900     2 444 400   9,67  
  Total       6 936 740   3 065 100   598 920   559 300   8 843 620      

# The vesting period in respect of part of the allocation made on 31 May 2006 was accelerated by six months, due to the fact that the Company had not issued any share incentive rights to eligible employees in 2005. The remaining contractual life of these rights is thus reduced by six months.

A valuation has been prepared using the stochastic model to determine the fair value of the share appreciation rights and the expense to be recognised during the year.

The inputs into stochastic model were as follows:

      31 December   31 December  
      2008   2007  
  Share price at balance sheet date   R108,50   R128,06  
  Expected life   1 to 6 years   1 to 6 years  
  Risk-free rate   6, 77% – 7,60%   8,40% to 10,04%  
  Expected volatility   40,39% – 46,52%   33,54% to 35,73%  
  Dividend yield   0,97%   1,11%  

Expected volatility was determined by calculating the historical volatility of MTN Group Limited's share price over the previous six years. The expected life used in the model has been adjusted, based on management's best estimate, for the effects of non-transferability, exercise restrictions and behavioural considerations. The expected dividend yield was determined based on historical data.

The nominations, remunerations, human resources and corporate governance committee periodically assesses the effectiveness of the Company's long-term incentive scheme, to ensure alignment with shareholder requirements and international best practice.

A revised share-based incentive scheme is currently being developed with the assistance of independent experts.

Equity compensation benefits for executive directors, the Group secretary and directors of major subsidiaries

Participation in the MTN Group Limited share schemes for the year ended 31 December 2008.

                              Exercise      
                  Number out-           price   Number out-  
      Strike           standing at           and sale   standing at  
      price   Vesting       31 December   Exercised   Exercise   price   31 December  
  Offer date   R   date   Offered   2007   2008   date   R   2008  
  PF Nhleko                                  
  2 September 2002   9,31   02/09/2004   477 740   82 740   82 740   22/12/2008   99,00    
  2 September 2002   9,31   02/09/2005   477 740   477 740   477 740   22/12/2008   99,00    
  2 September 2002   9,31   02/09/2006   716 610   716 610   716 610   22/12/2008   99,00    
  2 September 2002   9,31   02/09/2007   716 610   716 610   716 610   22/12/2008   99,00    
              2 388 700   1 993 700   1 993 700            
  21 November 2006   71,00   21/11/2008   172 133   172 133   103 280   22/12/2008   105,56   68 853  
  21 November 2006   71,00   21/11/2009   172 133   172 133               172 133  
  21 November 2006   71,00   21/11/2010   172 134   172 134               172 134  
              516 400   516 400   103 280           413 120  
  2 April 2007   98,50   02/04/2008   7 900   7 900               7 900  
  2 April 2007   98,50   02/04/2009   7 900   7 900               7 900  
  2 April 2007   98,50   02/04/2010   7 900   7 900               7 900  
              23 700   23 700               23 700  
  Total           2 928 800   2 533 800   2 096 980           436 820  
  RD Nisbet                                  
  2 September 2002   9,31   02/09/2004   187 160                  
  2 September 2002   9,31   02/09/2005   187 160                  
  2 September 2002   9,31   02/09/2006   280 740   280 740               280 740  
  2 September 2002   9,31   02/09/2007   280 740   280 740               280 740  
 
              935 800   561 480               561 480  
             
  1 December 2003   27,00   01/12/2005   12 900                  
  1 December 2003   27,00   01/12/2006   12 900   12 900               12 900  
  1 December 2003   27,00   01/12/2007   19 350   19 350               19 350  
  1 December 2003   27,00   01/12/2008   19 350   19 350               19 350  
 
              64 500   51 600               51 600  
             
  21 November 2006   71,00   21/11/2008   39 480   39 480               39 480  
  21 November 2006   71,00   21/11/2009   39 480   39 480               39 480  
  21 November 2006   71,00   21/11/2010   59 220   59 220               59 220  
  21 November 2006   71,00   21/11/2011   59 220   59 220               59 220  
 
              197 400   197 400               197 400  
             
  19 March 2008   126,99   19/03/2010   4 520                   4 520  
  19 March 2008   126,99   19/03/2011   4 520                   4 520  
  19 March 2008   126,99   19/03/2012   6 780                   6 780  
  19 March 2008   126,99   19/03/2013   6 780                   6 780  
              22 600                   22 600  
  Total           1 220 300   810 480               833 080  
  RS Dabengwa                                  
  2 September 2002   9,31   02/09/2004   66 140                  
  2 September 2002   9,31   02/09/2005   66 140                  
  2 September 2002   9,31   02/09/2006   99 210                  
  2 September 2002   9,31   02/09/2007   99 210                  
              330 700                  
                       
  1 December 2003   27,00   01/12/2005   58 220   58 220   58 220   14/10/2008   105,96    
  1 December 2003   27,00   01/12/2006   58 220   58 220   58 220   14/10/2008   105,96    
  1 December 2003   27,00   01/12/2007   87 330   87 330   43 560   14/10/2008   105,96   43 770  
  1 December 2003   27,00   01/12/2008   87 330   87 330               87 330  
              291 100   291 100   160 000           131 100  
                   
  21 November 2006   71,00   21/11/2008   8 680   8 680               8 680  
  21 November 2006   71,00   21/11/2009   8 680   8 680               8 680  
  21 November 2006   71,00   21/11/2010   13 020   13 020               13 020  
  21 November 2006   71,00   21/11/2011   13 020   13 020               13 020  
              43 400   43 400               43 400  
  31 May 2006   56,83   30/11/2007   26 960   26 960               26 960  
  31 May 2006   56,83   30/11/2008   26 960   26 960               26 960  
  31 May 2006   56,83   30/11/2009   40 440   40 440               40 440  
  31 May 2006   56,83   30/11/2010   40 440   40 440               40 440  
              134 800   134 800               134 800  
  19 March 2008   126,99   19/03/2010   14 440                   14 440  
  19 March 2008   126,99   19/03/2011   14 440                   14 440  
  19 March 2008   126,99   19/03/2012   21 660                   21 660  
  19 March 2008   126,99   19/03/2013   21 660                   21 660  
              72 200                   72 200  
  Total           872 200   469 300   160 000           381 500  
  C de Faria                                  
  21 November 2006   71,00   21/11/2008   69 720   69 720               69 720  
  21 November 2006   71,00   21/11/2009   69 720   69 720               69 720  
  21 November 2006   71,00   21/11/2010   104 580   104 580               104 580  
  21 November 2006   71,00   21/11/2011   104 580   104 580               104 580  
  Total           348 600   348 600               348 600  
  J Ramadan                                  
  21 November 2006   71,00   21/11/2008   69 720   69 720               69 720  
  21 November 2006   71,00   21/11/2009   69 720   69 720               69 720  
  21 November 2006   71,00   21/11/2010   104 580   104 580               104 580  
  21 November 2006   71,00   21/11/2011   104 580   104 580               104 580  
  Total           348 600   348 600               348 600  
  SL Botha                                  
  07 July 2003   16,81   07/07/2005   191 908                  
  07 July 2003   16,81   07/07/2006   191 908                  
  07 July 2003   16,81   07/07/2007   287 862   262 138               262 138  
  07 July 2003   16,81   07/07/2008   287 862   287 862               287 862  
              959 540   550 000               550 000  
  22 June 2007   96,00   22/06/2009   31 180   31 180               31 180  
  22 June 2007   96,00   22/06/2010   31 180   31 180               31 180  
  22 June 2007   96,00   22/06/2011   46 770   46 770               46 770  
  22 June 2007   96,00   22/06/2012   46 770   46 770               46 770  
              155 900   155 900               155 900  
  Total           1 115 440   705 900               705 900  
  KW Pienaar                                  
  2 September 2002   9,31   02/09/2004   124 120                  
  2 September 2002   9,31   02/09/2005   124 120                  
  2 September 2002   9,31   02/09/2006   186 180                  
  2 September 2002   9,31   02/09/2007   186 180                  
              620 600                  
  1 December 2004   40,50   01/12/2006   6 220                  
  1 December 2004   40,50   01/12/2007   6 220                  
  1 December 2004   40,50   01/12/2008   9 330   9 330               9 330  
  1 December 2004   40,50   01/12/2009   9 330   9 330               9 330  
              31 100   18 660               18 660  
  21 November 2006   71,00   21/11/2008   20 760   20 760               20 760  
  21 November 2006   71,00   21/11/2009   20 760   20 760               20 760  
  21 November 2006   71,00   21/11/2010   31 140   31 140               31 140  
  21 November 2006   71,00   21/11/2011   31 140   31 140               31 140  
              103 800   103 800               103 800  
  Total           755 500   122 460               122 460  
  PD Norman                                  
  2 September 2002   9,31   02/09/2004   110 020                  
  2 September 2002   9,31   02/09/2005   110 020   20               20  
  2 September 2002   9,31   02/09/2006   165 030   135 030   100 000   02/04/2008   134,20   35 030  
  2 September 2002   9,31   02/09/2007   165 030   165 030   50 000   12/12/2008   99,00   115 030  
              550 100   300 080   150 000           150 080  
  1 December 2004   40,50   01/12/2006   6 780   6 780               6 780  
  1 December 2004   40,50   01/12/2007   6 780   6 780               6 780  
  1 December 2004   40,50   01/12/2008   10 170   10 170               10 170  
  1 December 2004   40,50   01/12/2009   10 170   10 170               10 170  
              33 900   33 900               33 900  
  21 November 2006   71,00   21/11/2008   14 420   14 420               14 420  
  21 November 2006   71,00   21/11/2009   14 420   14 420               14 420  
  21 November 2006   71,00   21/11/2010   21 630   21 630               21 630  
  21 November 2006   71,00   21/11/2011   21 630   21 630               21 630  
              72 100   72 100               72 100  
  31 May 2006   56,83   30/11/2007   9 140   9 140               9 140  
  31 May 2006   56,83   30/11/2008   9 140   9 140               9 140  
  31 May 2006   56,83   30/11/2009   13 710   13 710               13 710  
  31 May 2006   56,83   30/11/2010   13 710   13 710               13 710  
              45 700   45 700               45 700  
  Total           701 800   451 780   150 000           301 780  
  SB Mtshali                                  
  31 May 2006   56,83   31/05/2008   10 600   10 600               10 600  
  31 May 2006   56,83   31/05/2009   10 600   10 600               10 600  
  31 May 2006   56,83   31/05/2010   15 900   15 900               15 900  
  31 May 2006   56,83   31/05/2011   15 900   15 900               15 900  
  Total           53 000   53 000               53 000  
  A Farroukh                                  
  21 November 2006   71,00   21/11/2008   55 580   55 580               55 580  
  21 November 2006   71,00   21/11/2009   55 580   55 580               55 580  
  21 November 2006   71,00   21/11/2010   83 370   83 370               83 370  
  21 November 2006   71,00   21/11/2011   83 370   83 370               83 370  
  Total           277 900   277 900               277 900  
  Z Bulbulia                                  
  28 September 2001   13,53   28/09/2003   15 180                  
  28 September 2001   13,53   28/09/2004   15 180   15 180               15 180  
  28 September 2001   13,53   28/09/2005   22 770   22 770               22 770  
  28 September 2001   13,53   28/09/2006   22 770   22 770               22 770  
              75 900   60 720               60 720  
  2 September 2002   9,31   02/09/2004   18 480   18 480               18 480  
  2 September 2002   9,31   02/09/2005   18 480   18 480               18 480  
  2 September 2002   9,31   02/09/2006   27 720   27 720               27 720  
  2 September 2002   9,31   02/09/2007   27 720   27 720               27 720  
              92 400   92 400               92 400  
  1 December 2003   27,00   01/12/2005   4 940   4 940               4 940  
  1 December 2003   27,00   01/12/2006   4 940   4 940               4 940  
  1 December 2003   27,00   01/12/2007   7 410   7 410               7 410  
  1 December 2003   27,00   01/12/2008   7 410   7 410               7 410  
              24 700   24 700               24 700  
  31 May 2006   56,83   30/11/2007   12 920   12 920               12 920  
  31 May 2006   56,83   30/11/2008   12 920   12 920               12 920  
  31 May 2006   56,83   30/11/2009   19 380   19 380               19 380  
  31 May 2006   56,83   30/11/2010   19 380   19 380               19 380  
              64 600   64 600               64 600  
  19 March 2008   126,99   19/03/2010   4 920                   4 920  
  19 March 2008   126,99   19/03/2011   4 920                   4 920  
  19 March 2008   126,99   19/03/2012   7 380                   7 380  
  19 March 2008   126,99   19/03/2013   7 380                   7 380  
              24 600                   24 600  
  Total           282 200   242 420               267 020  
  AR Bing                                  
  2 September 2002   9,31   02/09/2004   4 860                  
  2 September 2002   9,31   02/09/2005   4 860                  
  2 September 2002   9,31   02/09/2006   7 290                  
  2 September 2002   9,31   02/09/2007   7 290   7 290               7 290  
              24 300   7 290               7 290  
  1 December 2004   40,50   01/12/2006   6 670                  
  1 December 2004   40,50   01/12/2007   6 670   6 670               6 670  
  1 December 2004   40,50   01/12/2008   10 005   10 005               10 005  
  1 December 2004   40,50   01/12/2009   10 005   10 005               10 005  
              33 350   26 680               26 680  
  21 November 2006   71,00   21/11/2008   640   640               640  
  21 November 2006   71,00   21/11/2009   640   640               640  
  21 November 2006   71,00   21/11/2010   960   960               960  
  21 November 2006   71,00   21/11/2011   960   960               960  
              3 200   3 200               3 200  
  31 May 2006   56,83   30/11/2007   3 240   3 240               3 240  
  31 May 2006   56,83   30/11/2008   3 240   3 240               3 240  
  31 May 2006   56,83   30/11/2009   4 860   4 860               4 860  
  31 May 2006   56,83   30/11/2010   4 860   4 860               4 860  
              16 200   16 200               16 200  
  22 June 2007   96,00   22/06/2009   4 220   4 220               4 220  
  22 June 2007   96,00   22/06/2010   4 220   4 220               4 220  
  22 June 2007   96,00   22/06/2011   6 330   6 330               6 330  
  22 June 2007   96,00   22/06/2012   6 330   6 330               6 330  
              21 100   21 100               21 100  
  Total           98 150   74 470               74 470  

Directors’ shareholdings and dealings

The interests of the directors, alternate directors and directors of major subsidiaries in the ordinary shares of the Company were as follows:

      31 December   31 December  
      2008   2007  
  Director          
  DDB Band (beneficial)   14 023   14 023  
  PF Nhleko (beneficial)   3 304 451    
  J Ramadan(indirect beneficial)   20 000    
  J Ramadan(beneficial)   9 000    
  RD Nisbet (beneficial)   656 066   611 066  
  Z Bulbulia# (beneficial)   10 000   10 000  
  PD Norman# (non-beneficial)   10 000   10 000  
  Total   4 023 540   645 089  

#Major subsidiary director
†VP for the MENA region

Mr PF Nhleko concluded the following share purchases and sales during the financial year under review:

Number of   Purchase  
  Transaction date   shares   price  
  23 December 2008   18 741   98,84*  
  29 December 2008   1 116 092   99,00**  
  30 December 2008   931 183   107,12***  
  Total purchases   2 066 016      
Number of   Sales  
  Transaction date   shares   price  
  23 December 2008   15 073   95,00*  
  29 December 2008   877 608   102,94**  
  Total sales   892 681      
  Mr RD Nisbet concluded the following share purchases during the financial year under review:          
Number of   Purchase  
  Transaction date   shares   price  
  23 October 2008   45 000   83,61***  
  Mr J Ramadan concluded the following share purchases during the financial year under review:          
Number of   Purchase  
  Transaction date   shares   price  
  27 October 2008   9 000   74,95***  
  27October 2008   20 000   74,34***  
  Total   29 000      
  Mr PD Norman concluded the following share sales during the financial year under review:          
Number of   Sale  
  Transaction date   shares   price  
  02 April 2008   100 000   134,20**  
  15 December 2008   20 000   102,35**  
  19 December 2008   30 000   104,84**  
  Total   150 000      

    *Shares exercised under the Share Appreciation Rights Scheme
  **Shares exercised under the Share Options Scheme
***Shares purchased in the open market

Pursuant to the Alpine Trust unwind, the executive directors received the following number of MTN shares on 26 February 2009:

  – PF Nhleko 2 759 401 (0,15%)
  – RS Dabengwa 1 944 818 (0,10%)
  – RD Nisbet 1 944 818 (0,10%)

Shareholders are referred to the Integrated Business Report for the year ended 31 December 2007 in which it was disclosed that Mr PF Nhleko bought and restructured the forward purchase of 4 150 000 shares on numerous occasions between 24 May 2006 and 29 November 2007. During the year under review, Mr PF Nhleko continued to restructure the forward purchases and eventually closed out the trade of 27 October as follows: On 7 October 2008 the 4 150 000 forward purchased shares were restructured for a 13-month term to 30 November 2009 at forward price of R98,25. A put option was purchased at a strike price of R122,34 per share and the call option sold at a strike price of R129,09 in respect of the full 4 150 000 forward purchased MTN shares. Further, a call spread was concluded with a commercial bank for 5 000 000 contracts, buying a call strike price of R102,57 and selling a call strike price of R150,00 for 30 March 2009. On 27 October 2008, the 4 150 000 shares were restructured and early settled resulting in a purchase of 1 238 435 shares at R78,06.

Shareholders are referred to the Integrated Business Report for the year ended 31 December 2007 in which it was also disclosed that Mr PF Nhleko entered into a separate and independent 15-month term contract with a commercial bank on 28 December 2007 to acquire 15 893 822 shares at call strike price of R133,21 per share and sold calls at R195,00 per share. This trade was financed through a forward sale of 2 160 000 shares at R149,63 per share. During the year under review, Mr PF Nhleko restructured this trade as follows:
On 30 October 2008 a call spread was concluded with a commercial bank for 3 500 000 contracts buying a call strike price of R122 and selling a call strike price of R182 for 30 June 2009.

On 30 October 2008 a call spread was concluded with a commercial bank for 3 500 000 contracts, buying a call strike price of R135 and selling a call strike price of R195 for 17 September 2009.

Directors’ interests in MTN Group held through Newshelf 664 (Proprietary) Limited and derived from the Alpine Trust

Newshelf 664 (Proprietary) Limited ("Newshelf 664") owns 277,89 million MTN Group shares (equivalent to 14,89% (December 2007: 13,06%) of the issued capital of MTN Group). Newshelf 664 exercises the voting rights in respect of such shares. Initially, 243,5 million MTN Group shares were acquired from Transnet Limited ("Transnet") at an average price of R13,90 per share between December 2002 and March 2003. A further 34,39 million MTN Group shares were acquired from the Government Employees Pension Fund, represented by the Public Investment Corporation Limited ("PIC") on 22 December 2008, at a price of R99,00 per share ("the special dividend MTN shares").

The special dividend MTN shares were declared as a dividend in specie on the same date to the Alpine Trust ("the trust"), as the holder of the single ordinary share in Newshelf 664. The trust simultaneously distributed the special dividend MTN shares (except for 300 000 shares retained for costs) to its beneficiaries, in accordance with the trust's trust deed. The special dividend MTN shares were delivered to the trust's beneficiaries on 4 February 2009. As at 22 December 2008, the trust further agreed to sell its ordinary share in Newshelf 664 to the PIC for a nominal value. The trust has no further interest in Newshelf 664.

The trust's main objective is the advancement of black economic empowerment. In undertaking the distribution to its beneficiaries, as aforesaid, the trust has fulfilled its objectives. The benefits from the trust that have been distributed to MTN directors, comprising MTN Group shares, were disclosed on SENS on 9 February 2009, are further detailed below, and are included in this report in the directors' direct holdings of MTN shares at 31 December 2008.

The trust has six trustees, two of whom are directors of MTN Group, namely PF Nhleko and RS Dabengwa. The other trustees, being I Charnley, W Lucas-Bull, PM Jenkins (Chairperson) and Z Sithole, are independent. Furthermore, all the directors of Newshelf 664 have been appointed by the trust, such directors being PF Nhleko, I Charnley, RD Nisbet and RS Dabengwa (jointly, "the Newshelf 664 directors"). The Newshelf 664 directors are also included among the beneficiaries of the trust. Consequently, the interests of the Newshelf 664 directors in respect of the MTN Group shares held by Newshelf 664 are as follows:

  • As a result of being trustees of the trust, PF Nhleko and RS Dabengwa, together with the other trustees, have a nominal indirect, non-beneficial interest in the MTN Group shares that are currently held by Newshelf 664.
  • As a result of being directors of Newshelf 664, the Newshelf 664 directors have an indirect, beneficial interest in respect of the voting rights pertaining to the MTN Group shares that are currently held by Newshelf 664.
  • During 2008, as a result of being beneficiaries of the trust, the Newshelf 664 directors had an indirect, beneficial interest in the MTN Group shares that were held by Newshelf 664. This beneficial interest was in the form of rights to participate in a predetermined ratio (“the participation ratio”) in the net assets of the trust. The participation ratio of each Newshelf 664 director, who are currently also executive directors of MTN Group Limited are as follows:
  – PF Nhleko 7,9270% (2006: 7,9270%)
  – RS Dabengwa 5,5869% (2006: 5,5869%)
  – RD Nisbet 5,5869% (2006: 5,5869%)

Subject to the terms and conditions of the trust deed, the rights to participate in the net assets of the trust vested in the above persons in full at the end of 2008 and the special dividend MTN shares were distributed to all beneficiaries of the trust in accordance with their participation ratios. As at the end of 2008, the beneficiaries of the trust ceased to hold any beneficial interest in Newshelf 664.

In addition, the Newshelf 664 directors have exercised an option to participate in 0,23% of the economic benefits attaching to the “B” class redeemable preference shares and the “B” class participating preference share held by the PIC, as funders to Newshelf 664, for which option the Newshelf 664 directors jointly paid an amount of R5 million. The capital acquisition consideration paid by each Newshelf 664 director was as follows:

       
  Director   Consideration paid
  PF Nhleko   R1 612 577
  I Charnley   R1 129 141
  RS Dabengwa   R1 129 141
  RD Nisbet   R1 129 141
  Total   R5 000 000
       

The Newshelf 664 directors thus have an indirect beneficial interest in the MTN Group Limited shares acquired by Newshelf 664 to the extent that the proceeds of such shares (dividends and capital) are required to service and settle the preference share funding provided by the PIC, but only to the extent of the proportion that their funding of the preference shares bears to the total PIC funding.

The following persons, being directors of MTN Group Limited and its major subsidiaries and the MTN Group secretary, received the following numbers of MTN shares from the Alpine Trust, pursuant to the distribution of the special dividend MTN shares:

       
  Director   Consideration paid
  PF Nhleko   2 759 401
  RS Dabengwa   1 944 818
  RD Nisbet   1 944 818
  SL Botha   404 996
  PD Norman   404 996
  KP Pienaar   404 996
  Z Bulbulia   69 300
  A Bing   23 787
  SB Mtshali   7 031
  Total   7 964 143
       

Directorate and Group secretary

The composition and profiles of the board of directors of MTN Group.

The Group secretary is Ms SB Mtshali, whose business and postal addresses are set out below:

       
  Business address   Postal address
  216, 14th Avenue   Private Bag 9955
  Fairland   Cresta
  2195   2118

During the financial year under review, the following MTN Group directors resigned from the board:

       
  Director   Resignation date
  MA Ramphele   18 March 2008
  L Woicke   18 March 2008
  AH Sharbatly   19 June 2008

In accordance with the articles of association of the Company, one-third of the board is required to retire by rotation, at each annual general meeting. Retiring directors are those who have been in office the longest since their last re-election and directors who have been appointed between annual general meetings.

The directors retiring by rotation in terms of the articles of association at the forthcoming annual general meeting are Messrs RS Dabengwa, AT Mikati, MJN Njeke and J van Rooyen. The profiles of the directors retiring by rotation can be viewed in the notice to shareholders.

Profiles of the directors seeking re-election are contained in the notice of the fourteenth annual general meeting.

Interests of directors and officers

During the year under review, no contracts were entered into in which directors and officers of the Company had an interest which significantly affected the business of the Group. The directors had no interest in any third party or company responsible for managing any of the business activities of the Group. The emoluments of executive directors are determined by the Group NRHR & CG committee and approved by the board. No long-term service contracts exist between executive directors and the Company, with the exception of the contract of service between the Group president and CEO and the Company, of which the first contract had commenced on 1 July 2002 and terminated on 30 June 2007. The contract was subsequently renewed at the annual general meeting held on 13 June 2007 until 30 June 2010.

Material resolutions

MTN Nigeria Communications Limited passed a special resolution on 26 November 2008 authorising its merger with VGC Communications Limited, retaining the name MTN Nigeria Communications Limited. MTN Nigeria Communications Limited is a major subsidiary of the Company thus the transaction requires disclosure in terms of the JSE listings requirements.

Mergers and acquisitions

Details of the MTN Group’s acquisitions and disposals are presented in the Group president and CEO’s statement and the annual financial statements.

Post-balance sheet events

Subsequent to year-end, the Group acquired 100% of Verizon South Africa (Proprietary) Limited and the remaining 59% in I-Talk (Proprietary) Limited.

Property, plant and equipment

There were no changes in the nature of property, plant and equipment nor in the policy regarding their use during the financial year under review.

American depository receipt facility

A sponsored American depository receipt (ADR) facility has been established. This ADR facility is sponsored by the Bank of New York and details of the administrators are reflected under administration.

Borrowing powers

In terms of the articles of association of the Company, the borrowing powers of the Company are unlimited, however, all borrowings by the MTN Group are subject to limitations expressed in the treasury policy of the MTN Group. The details of borrowings appear in note 17 of the annual financial statements

Going concern

The directors have reviewed the MTN Group’s budget and cash flow forecast for the year to 31 December 2008. On the basis of this review and in the light of the current financial position and existing borrowing facilities, the directors are satisfied that the MTN Group has access to adequate resources to continue in operational existence for the foreseeable future and is a going concern and have continued to adopt the going concern basis in preparing the financial statements.

Auditors

PricewaterhouseCoopers Inc. and SizweNtsaluba vsp will continue in office as joint auditors in accordance with section 270(2) of the Companies Act. The audit committee reviewed the independence of the auditors during the year under review and declared itself satisfied that the auditors were independent of the Company.